Research Review: “The problem of anti-feminist ‘manfluencer’ Andrew Tate in Australian schools: women teachers’ experiences of resurgent male supremacy”

As a therapist working with numerous survivors of violence and trauma against women, I have seen firsthand the devastating effects of domestic violence (DV) and femicide. The rates of DV and femicide in Australia remain alarmingly high, and it is crucial to examine the underlying causes to effectively address and mitigate these issues. Recent research conducted by Dr. Stephanie Wescott, Professor Steven Roberts, and PhD candidate Xuenan Zhao at Monash University sheds light on a disturbing trend in Australian schools: the influence of 'manfluencer' culture, epitomized by figures like Andrew Tate, on young boys' behavior and attitudes towards women.

The Research Findings

The study, "The problem of anti-feminist 'manfluencer' Andrew Tate in Australian schools: women teachers' experiences of resurgent male supremacy," delves into the significant impact of toxic masculinity promoted by social media influencers on the school environment. The research involved qualitative interviews with 30 women teachers across public and private schools in Australia and revealed a troubling resurgence of male supremacy and misogynistic behavior among young boys.

Adoption of Toxic Beliefs: Boys are increasingly adopting themes and beliefs promoted by Andrew Tate, leading to significant changes in their behavior and attitudes towards women. This resurgence of traditional patriarchal norms has resulted in overt displays of authority and dominance over women teachers and female students​

Behavioral Changes and Harassment: Women teachers reported a notable increase in sexual harassment and misogynistic behavior from male students. Boys were found to mimic Tate's messaging, making jokes and comments that undermine female authority and reflect skewed gender power dynamics​.

Impact on Women Teachers: The experiences of women teachers have become increasingly combative and unsafe. They face interactions that challenge their gender and authority, exacerbated by the return to face-to-face schooling post-COVID lockdowns and the rise in popularity of figures like Tate​

Influence on Peer Relationships: The study also noted how boys' interactions with Andrew Tate's content shape their views and subsequently their interactions in the classroom. This influence contributes to a hostile environment for female students as well, who often find themselves targets of these reinforced patriarchal behaviors​

The Broader Implications

The influence of 'manfluencer' culture on young boys' behavior in schools is not an isolated issue but part of a larger societal problem. Misogyny and toxic masculinity are deeply embedded in many aspects of our culture, and these attitudes significantly contribute to the high rates of DV and femicide. When young boys internalize these harmful beliefs, it can lead to aggressive and violent behavior towards women, both in school settings and later in life.

The link between misogyny and DV is well-documented. According to a 2017 report by Australia's National Research Organisation for Women's Safety (ANROWS), attitudes that support gender inequality and traditional gender roles are significant drivers of violence against women. Misogynistic beliefs perpetuate a culture where violence against women is tolerated and normalized, leading to severe consequences for women's safety and well-being.

Recommendations for Schools

To combat the pervasive influence of toxic masculinity and 'manfluencer' culture, the study by Wescott and Roberts recommends several comprehensive school-level responses:

1. Ongoing Education: Schools must implement continuous and in-depth education on respectful relationships and gender equality. One-off sessions or punitive measures are insufficient. Instead, ongoing dialogue and educational programs are essential to challenge harmful gender stereotypes and promote healthy relationships.​

2. Support for Teachers: Teachers need support in navigating challenging conversations about gender and authority. Schools should provide resources and training to help teachers manage and counteract the negative influences of 'manfluencers'​.

3. Active School Leadership: School leadership should play a crucial role in addressing these issues. Leaders must prioritize creating a safe and inclusive environment for all students and staff by addressing toxic behaviors and promoting positive change​.

4. Engaging Parents and Community: Schools should involve parents and the broader community in efforts to challenge toxic masculinity. Educational workshops and resources can help parents understand the influence of 'manfluencer' culture and provide them with tools to counteract these messages at home​.

5. Promoting Positive Role Models: Introducing students to positive male role models who exemplify respectful and egalitarian attitudes towards women can help counteract the negative influences of 'manfluencers.' Schools can invite speakers, organize mentorship programs, and highlight positive behaviors in their curricula.

A Call to Action

As a therapist committed to addressing violence and trauma against women, I urge school communities, parents, and policymakers to take these findings seriously. The influence of toxic masculinity and misogyny in schools is not just an educational issue but a societal one that has far-reaching implications for the safety and well-being of women. By implementing comprehensive educational programs and fostering a culture of respect and equality, we can work towards reducing the rates of DV and femicide and create a safer environment for future generations.

It is imperative that we address these issues head-on, recognising the profound impact that 'manfluencer' culture has on young minds. This research provides a crucial starting point for conversations and actions aimed at dismantling harmful beliefs and fostering a more inclusive, respectful society for all.

For more information on the research, you can access the full paper here. Let's work together to challenge and dismantle the harmful beliefs that perpetuate violence against women and build a more inclusive and respectful society.